Click To Go Back To The Main
www.GlenStephens.com Stamps Homepage
Welcome! You are visitor to www.GlenStephens.com
Glen Stephens A dangerous ring of ten ebay "handles" selling forged Australian, New
Zealand and New Guinea stamps and cancels was uncovered and dismantled
Monthly "Stamp News" Market Tipster Column
ebay forgery ring smashed
The ten ebay "handles" appeared to be inter-connected and were selling bogus material to unsuspecting stamp buyers on the large ebay website.
These unsuspecting buyers were paying many $100s for stamps that would not be saleable for even 10% of that sum to real dealers.
Much of the detective work involved in un-ravelling this dangerous ring was un-covered by members on a new postage stamp Bulletin Board - stampboards.com
Members of stampboards.com reported suspicious sellers, and many offered links to other sellers who were offering the same material. The pattern slowly emerged.
In several cases it was shown these ebay "handles" were bidding up each other's material. This is known in the ebay world as "shill" bidding. It is outlawed, but ebay does not seem to take action or be bothered, unless alerted to it rather forcibly.
A dangerous ring of ten ebay "handles" selling forged Australian, New
Zealand and New Guinea stamps and cancels was uncovered and dismantled
The ten faker ebay IDs were - aw1940, aussiestampsales, nswstamps, modlink2002, stampbuyers, indepbrokers, george0mighty, wynstoninvest, gregbear_61 and bexapunk101
The last seller in this list "bexapunk101" for some reason ebay overlooked banning, and the web link above contains evidence of the fakes and shill bidding associated with this account.
If anyone reading this is an ebay member they may care to re-report this seller.
Stamp dealer body APTA also got involved, and I am told have senior stamp collector contacts who work in the NSW Police, who also are placing colleagues on this fellow's tail.
I am aware of one NSW APTA member reporting this matter direct to a senior member of NSW Police as a matter of fraud.
APTA members internationally have been briefed on the perpetrator and his many fake ebay "handles", and none of them will likely be conned into buying any of them, as they are now fully aware of what is out there.
I kept APTA President Michael Eastick fully informed on new developments, and fellow columnist Simon Dunkerley was active in adding pieces to the jigsaw puzzle of this mass of inter-connected seller names.
ebay moved, and de-registered these accounts in April, based on dealer and stampboard member complaints.
The seller's oxygen is then starved. No outlets = no reason to keep offering the dud stamps, as he will get lumbered yet again.
A job well done by all involved I'd say, and a large pat of the back to all concerned.
A hundred sets of vigilant eyes are now watching ebay for his possible re-appearance with new fake handles.
This person is a fully trained and qualified medico, and one wonders what drives someone that smart into this kind of petty fraud.
He knows enough about stamps to make more money selling legitimate things for the same expenditure of effort, but this all seems to be a giant game to him - "fleece the ebay bunnies".
Most fakes offered were Australian official perfins and overprints, and a small range of fake cancels and overprints were also involved - including a few New Zealand issues.
Some fakes were fairly convincing, and many were quite appalling. Where some ebay buyers get their brains from, one really wonders.
When one sees total obvious fake rubbish attracting a raft of high bids to $190 for comically bad things like the stamp illustrated nearby it is of concern.
It was pretty clearly fake cancelled only a few days before it was listed, with a cheap rubber stamp pad, and a quite laughable rubber cancel. The jet black ink still looks like it was damp!
The 10/- NWPI under-lying Kangaroo stamp would have been genuine, but probably thinned, toned or heavily hinged. These stamps are worth a lot more "used" than mint, therefore this con-man glued it to a piece of brown paper and applied the absurd fake cancel.
This turned a $20 retail probably thinned stamp into a $190 "fine used on piece" example. At least to ebay buyers it did.
To the buyers of $10,000s of forged junk from this crook ..... kiss your money goodbye is my guess.
Next time you plan to spend $600 apiece on fake stamps on ebay as some of these folks did, please check them out first with a REAL dealer for a once over and advice, before you get possibly conned.
Or visit a site like stampboards.com and post the images of what you plan to buy - and first seek input from experts.
An established dealer will be in business next week, next month, next year - and usually next decade if you end up with something you might want a refund on.
As we can all see, these ebay cons are always out of business sooner rather than later, (often a day after the sale closes!) and your only recourse is to whistle in the wind for your $600 refund.
ebay absolutely do not want to know, and even PayPal do not want to know it seems.
ebay and PayPal make money EVERY time a sale occurs. Whether it is a fake stamp or not is apparently not of any interest to them at the end of the day.
Unless a watertight case is laid out in front of them, nothing generally occurs.
That dodgy seller joanne620 continues to sell over-described junk at will, despite endless complaints to ebay - from ebay users and the stamp trade.
On May 10 the usual gaggle of ill-informed ebay nuts bid up a yellowed gum, almost certainly forged pair of 1937 robes "Specimen" overprints to $775 from "joanne620". No warranty and dodgy photos, yet they are paying $775 for a set I would offer them just $50 for tomorrow. Terrifying.
This hurts all dealers and genuine collectors as when these folks finally get the bad news broken to them they have been ripped off, they often leave stamp collecting forever.
One member of stampboards.com who bought forgeries from one of these now banned handles, applied to get an refund as he paid via PayPal.
After taking an eternity completing PayPal on-line forms and paperwork, and obtaining expert opinions to add to them that the stamps were fake, he got told there was a $25 "administrative" fee from any refund they might approve.
So much for the "pay with PayPal and you'll always be safe" mantra that ebay continually espouses. (ebay own PayPal of course!) Even buying outright proven fakes you will not get all your money back.
Hall Of Shame
One very useful resource for checking up on ebay stamp con-men is www.scads.org who has a "Hall Of Shame. This is a US based ebay watchdog since 2002, that was alerted by stampboards.com to all the banned sellers above. joanne620" is also listed. (The only Australian active ebay seller to be named.)
Sold for $56
As I typed
this article May 12, the stampboards folks pointed out
another ridiculous item being offered on ebay closing that
day - lot 270116543182
Ross Smith Vignette
For the benefit of these who do NOT want to pay good money for reprints, here is a summary of the REAL item!
The high priced "Local" item most collectors think of immediately is the 1920 Ross Smith 'Vignette'. This is more a semi-official issue than a "Local" or "Cinderella".
It was ordered by the Prime Minister's Department (by no less than PM "Billy" Hughes!) via Treasury, and printed by the Note Printing Branch on watermarked paper - the same wide crown watermark as we find on 1914 KGV heads, or "Second" watermark Kangaroos.
For the dozen hopeful folks who ask me each year if their 'rare' vignette is really valuable ....... just hold it up to the light. If there is NO watermark you have one of the many types of near worthless reprints done over the years.
Some are very crude like the rubbish sold on ebay above, and some were far better productions of quite fair standard.
Some are so roughly printed virtually none of the perf holes are punched out - like the one shown nearby.
In ALL cases, the colour is quite wrong, not being the deep steel blue of the genuine as you can see in the photo nearby.
The REAL McCoy!
So, it is not a "Local" or a 'Cinderella" strictly speaking, but in my view is an officially printed label and should be more correctly termed a "semi-official" production. All the same a lot still exist as mint or used stamps, or on cover.
A fine MUH sheetlet sells for about $A20,000 and a really superb cover was auctioned in recent times in the region of $A50,000.
There are still quite a number of these existing, either as mint sheetlets as illustrated nearby, or on covers.
Dealer Simon Dunkerley once told me when he was working at an auction house lotting up the Sir Hudson Fysh collection, he recalls there were at least a dozen flown covers bearing this 1920 'stamp' carelessly dispersed among it.
Mentioned above is a new stamp bulletin board -
There are already very active members from all over the globe - in Asia, Europe, USA, Canada, Australia and New Zealand. From Newfoundland to Tasmania - with the great bulk of the members being based in Australasia.
A very busy stampboard is up and running in just two short months of existence, with about 10,000 member posts made already as you can see - posting on everything you can possibly imagine related to stamp collecting.
There are forums for - Cinderellas and Revenues, New Issues, errors, ebay, numismatics, Rarities, coming auctions, "Stamps Wanted", Club News, Reference Books, "Exchange Partners" etc.
Members helped identify an apparently unknown Australian "Pamaba" Cinderella recently - illustrated nearby. Full details on the board.
Type into Google the words "Stamp Bulletin Board" or "Postage Stamp Chat" etc, and you can see the word is already out on this new venture. We are the number one Google match worldwide.
The Bulletin Board software allows actual stamp photos to be posted up quickly and FREE from your own computer, so if you are selling, buying, or wanting ID help on anything, this is the place to load your stamps or numismatic photos.
There are many hundreds of stamp photos posted up large in full colour to comment on, or to learn from.
The ebay forger summarised above was uncovered by the board posting up large images of his fakes. Often of the same stamps before and AFTER he faked them!
If dealers have an auction or special sale schedules - by all means post the details. If you are attending or running any stamp shows - add the details and dates and cost there. If you distribute a new catalogue of anything or handbook - add the details and photos. All free.
For all members of stamp clubs and societies there is a board where you can add all the details of what you are doing, location, dates and times of meeting, annual dues etc. You can even load each stamp club/society journal up FREE.
If your Club or Society is NOT listed already - please bring this Bulletin Board to the attention of your Hon. Secretary or President. Listing all your club details to a world audience clearly makes it stronger - at no cost.
Clubs and collectors and dealers can load color photos of anything they wish.
We have light hearted time wasting threads, jokes threads and cartoons, and a few silly things like this one - which also shows how quickly photos can be loaded up - www.stampboards.com/viewtopic.php?p=5412
All members can have colour stamp "avatars" totally of their choice, and all members achieve fun "Star" ratings based on their posting history.
Stampboards even has a numismatic Forum where new product can be posted and illustrated and discussed if you wish.
There is a team of 12 volunteer Moderators on hand to remove any spam the moment it appears. There are NO pop-ups, NO annoying ads of any kind, NO banners and NO spyware.
A lot of collectors and dealers are new to Bulletin Boards and we have set up a lot of easy to follow "How To" help threads to address commonly asked questions - www.stampboards.com/viewforum.php?f=18
Stampboards.com is not any a threat to any magazine - indeed "Stamp News" publisher Kevin Morgan is one of our most active posters and supporters. (Editor's note - I was just about to start such a board when I saw Glen had done so!)
The internet is "immediate" - something no monthly magazine can ever be. If you are really moving with the times, do taken a moment to check out stampboards.com today!
FREE! Just click here... see exactly what my lots cost in your currency.
If you would like to be notified of updates to this website, Click HERE.If have any questions,
I am a Member Of
Full Time Stamp Dealer in Australia for over 25 years.
Full Time Stamp Dealer in Australia for over 25 years.
Life Member - American Stamp Dealers' Association. (New York)
Also Member - Philatelic Traders' Society. (London) ANDA. (Melbourne) American Philatelic Society, etc
Sydney's BIGGEST STAMP BUYER:
Post me ANYTHING via Registered
Mail for my same-day cheque.
"Lothlórien", 4 The
Tor Walk, CASTLECRAG (Sydney), N.S.W. 2068
Every credit card shown is
accepted WITHOUT fee.
Earn Frequent Flier points while buying at bargain prices!
ALL prices are in weak Ozzie Dollars. I charge NO nasty, nasty
"Buyer's Commission" on stamps like nearly every "Auction" does.