I want every dealer reader of this article to be honest. Would you even take a
second glance if you saw hinged on an album page the ordinary looking 2¢ stamp
Well I'll be the first to answer and admit I would NOT. It is a stamp usually
worth a dollar or so mint, of the exceedingly common pre-WWI 2¢ red George
This hinged mint copy was auctioned June 12 in New York City for $US176,000 - or
nearly exactly $A250,000 at the time I typed this article. The auctioneer was
Robert A. Siegel.
Just sold for $A250,000
This is a new record price for a single twentieth century USA
stamp. More amazingly - it is not an error stamp or missing colour or inverted
centre etc - this is a regularly issued USA 1914 sheet stamp. It sold for nearly
6 times current Scott catalogue value.
Some readers might imagine this huge price is due to the "7082" marginal plate
number. Nope. It is my view the stamp would have sold for a similarly huge price
even if it had NO plate number or marking whatever on the margin.
Even more remarkable is that this stamp changed hands in very recent times at
major auctions for prices a very small fraction of this recent realisation.
It sold for only $US7,150 in October 1998 at the legendary and highly publicised
Robert Zoellner collection sale - also auctioned by Robert A. Siegel. Zoellner
had the only "complete" USA collection ever formed and it sold for over $US8
million. The 1c "Z" Grill in that sale reached the all-time record price for a
single USA stamp at $US935,000 - and the bidding paddle was held up by a 12 year
old boy - son of Mystic President Donald Sundman!
The buyer Mystic Stamp Company then tried to sell the stamp for $US2,500,000
(then $A3,750,000) soon after and they still own it, as no-one would pay their
modest profit margin asked of over $US1,500,000! They took full back page ads in
"Linn's" shortly after buying it, with a coupon to complete at the base saying:
“My check or money order for $US2,500,00 is enclosed. NY State residents please
add correct sales tax”. No mention of credit cards ANYWHERE on the coupon.
Still unsold at
Apart from the Zoellner pedigree, this 2¢ example was once in the even more
legendary Colonel Green collection. (son of Hetty the “Witch of Wall Street”)
Green was the eccentric millionaire who purchased and broke up for sale the
unique sheet of the 24¢ "Inverted Jenny" airmail - among other things.
Green initially planned to burn all the 19 straight edge copies as they looked
"un-attractive". He tossed them aside and they were later found literally stuck
together after he died. They first appeared on the market in 1942, and the gum
had been washed off all 19 copies in order to separate them.
In September 1991 the unique "Inverted Jenny" plate block of 4 sold for
$US1,200,000 dollars to a broadcast executive. Ted Turner of CNN/Jane Fonda fame
was rumoured to be the buyer. However, I digress totally from this 2¢ red story!
This exact same 2¢ stamp was also auctioned later on in September 2000 - and
once again by Robert A. Siegel where this time it bought "only" $US9,900.
18 times increase since 2000
This new price is nearly 18 times more than it sold for in 2000 - indeed
$166,100 more. And sold via the same auctioneer so one assumes the names on
their mailing list for all three sales were similar, which is even more curious.
Why the huge increase?
The answer is simple ... it is because Scott Catalogues recently changed the
catalogue number for this stamp. In the 2003 Scott USA specialised, all of the
1914 compound perforation issues (1¢, 2¢, 5¢) were given "major" catalogue
numbers for the first time.
Used copy sold for
Scott also created 3 new spaces for these stamps in the widely used Scott
"National" album. Therefore everyone who collects via this relatively
"simplified" album suddenly needed these stamps to be complete.
Previously these 3 stamps were only listed as "small letter" (minor) varieties
under Scott numbers 424, 425 and 428. The new "full" Scott number for this stamp
is 423B and catalogue value in the 2004 catalogue is $US30,000 mint and
The reason Scott 423b is worth $250,000 and not the one dollar I'd have placed
on it will become apparent if you carefully examine the photograph. It is
perforated gauge 10 across the top and perf 12 down each side, i.e. the stamp is
compound perforation 10x12. The normal issue Scott 425 is perf 10x10, which even
mint is worth peanuts.
There are 29 used copies documented of this rare stamp and this example is the
only mint copy recorded. This is why I surmise it would have obtained a huge sum
even without the selvedge plate number, which in the case of a unique non error
stamp is largely irrelevant.
The same auction had 4 of the 29 known used copies and they too all got good
prices - best being $US20,350 on the Scott catalogue value of $US10,000.
USA Museum to destroy a million
I noticed the stamp realisation above when reading "Linn's Stamp News"
which magazine I am the South Pacific correspondent. Also in "Linn's" for much
of this year has been the ongoing furore in the USA over the archive sales of
USA revenue stamps.
This matter has received scant if any coverage outside America, so I will try
and summarise the last 6 months of this saga below. You will hardly believe it.
The National Postal Museum (NPM) in Washington discovered 7.8 million USA mint
revenue stamps on hand that were taking up space, and they did not need, so they
decided to destroy most of them and sell off the balance. They announced this
January 2004 in a press release to the stamp world. NPM is a division of the
The stamps were transferred to them by the US Internal Revenue Service between
1954 and 1977. The holding comprises approximately 7.8 million stamps of which
there are nearly 1,900 distinct revenue stamp varieties. In many cases, there
are up to 50,000 copies of a stamp.
Perversely NPM claimed the funds raised would be used to purchase the few USA
stamps they needed to complete their simplified collection. The results of the
stamp sales above shows they need all the bucks they can raise! In January they
claimed they hoped to raise between $US1-2 million from these sales. Lately they
have been far more circumspect and secretive.
When this silly idea was announced in January the bureaucrats announced some 7.3
million of the 7.8 million revenue stamps would be destroyed or loaned to other
institutions or sold. The vast bulk of this 7.3 million stamps were earmarked to
Predictably there was a RIOT among USA dealers and collectors. Led by leading
revenues dealer Eric Jackson, they waged a relentless public campaign to have
the NPM re-assess its foolish decision.
In April the NPM flip-flopped and revised the number to be destroyed, but still
indicated a few million were to be destroyed. The outcry continued anew.
The campaign worked, and the NPM's latest flip-flop (as of mid July) is to now
to sell 5.8 million of the 7.8 million stamps they own. Like all Bureaucrats,
they never admit defeat, and never admit stupidity. All they are now saying is
that all on their own they made this wise decision.
An offer they DID refuse
Jackson had made the NPM look very foolish and continued by taking a page ad in
"Linn's" June 28, headed "Money To Burn." He offered to pay the
NPM $US1,000,000 for the million or so stamps they still planned to destroy -
with a photo of his pre-filled out cheque. Jackson maintains that to burn ANY of
the stamps was philatelic vandalism.
Indeed, the mission statement of the NPM includes this line: “The National
Postal Museum, through its collections and library, is dedicated to the
preservation, study and presentation of postal history and philately.”
Burning a million stamps is difficult to fit into that description.
Jackson made good arguments such as: "There is only one recorded example of the
1.7¢ Wine stamp (Scott RE182D cat $25,000 used) in private hands. The museum has
50,000 mint copies, but its fact sheet states that only three examples will be
sold. The owner of the one stamp is not pleased, but neither are scores, or
possibly hundreds or thousands, of other collectors who might like to own one of
these stamps. The museum is attempting to manipulate the rarity of this stamp."
"I believe the 49,000-plus copies that are about to be destroyed are worth more
than the three they are planning to sell" Jackson continued.
Which of course any 6 year old can see is clearly correct. If raising funds is
the stated aim for the NPM why only sell THREE copies and destroy 49,000
perfectly good examples?
The low face value 1.7¢ stamp Jackson refers to is in similar size, colour and
design as the $400 example illustrated nearby, and is also inscribed as being
from the 1941 series (but was issued in 1951/4.) This stamp shown is Scott
Scott only lists this $400 value as used at $US12,000 and it is not priced or
known mint in collector hands. So even if the NPM releases the 2944 mint copies
it holds, that USED price would likely not alter - nor its value for the present
owner. Like many German 1920s "inflation" stamps that are worth pennies mint and
$1000s used, the four existing used copies are well documented, have correct
cancels and doubtless are expertised.
Unknown in mint
Jackson points out and accepts that there are
many things he has in stock that will come down heavily in value over what he
paid if the entire holding is sold. He argues on the other side of the coin that
interest in this Revenues field will increase greatly if a large number of fresh
mint unhinged stamps come on to the market at attractive prices. Jackson's
stock, and existing collector holdings will clearly gain in value overall
because of it.
There are no losers that I can see. NPM gets the $ millions it needs and
importantly - acts responsibly by dispersing all the stamps. Collectors and
dealers get wonderful new stock. Many new collectors of this field will thus
The NPM in their wisdom announced in June 2004 they are now seeking submissions
from auction houses to offer their stamps for sale starting late 2004. And like
all bureaucrats have set all sorts of zany rules and conditions and submissions
required from any interested parties - all outlined on their website.
NPM have declared in writing this month: "the destruction of the surplus copies
will be completed prior to the sale". This article and the continued USA
pressure is aimed at trying to overturn that ominous sounding proclamation.
Several members of the Museum's "Council of Philatelists" include
representatives of large auction houses. These auctions are Robert A. Siegel,
Spink of London, Matthew Bennett International and Harmers Switzerland.
Surprise, surprise - these auction houses are not precluded from tendering to
auction the surplus. All very strange.
Many other dealers and prominent identities who do not represent auctions are
also part of this "Council", including Janet Klug, current President of the
massive 50,000 member American Philatelic Society, also two past APS Presidents.
I also noted Jim Kloetzel, Scott Catalog Editor - even Donald Sundman, current
owner of the pricey "Z" Grill mentioned above etc.
Why these philatelic stalwarts have not torpedoed this planned destruction long
ago has not been explained. Three APS Presidents seemingly going along with such
destruction seems incongruous to me, and surely at odds with the APS
One prominent member Arthur Morowitz resigned from this "Council" in a very
public manner June 23. I have met Arthur in Sydney, and he is a very savvy
dealer, and runs the last street level stamp shop surviving in New York City. He
is a past President of the American Stamp Dealer's Association.
Morowitz in May 2003 purchased for $US3,068,000 the entire archive of the United
Nations Postal Administration - and sold it intact (for a profit!) to Greg
Manning who broke it down for auction. So Arthur knows a thing or two about
archive material. He also bought intact the archives of the American Bank Note
Company some years earlier which contained much valuable philatelic material.
A spokesman for Swiss auctioneer David Feldman later claimed re the UN archive:
"This is the world record high price for a large lot". The lot comprised many
dozens of cartons of unique material. It was all shipped from UN headquarters NYC to Geneva and then shipped back again when Morowitz/Manning purchased it!
Morowitz's resignation letter to Allen Kane the NPA chief, said in part: "The
reason for my leaving is one issue and one issue only - the destruction of
collectible revenue stamps rather than the sale of these to the philatelic
community. To destroy these items held for collector purposes for over 50 years
"Why destroy the revenue stamps and the future happiness of 100s of collectors
and the potential to expand a wonderful hobby" Morowitz continued.
Reading the ongoing saga, and a recent snippy letter from him to "Linn's" on
this matter, I get the feeling Allen Kane (NPM chief) is acting like all pretty
bureaucrats when he does not get his own way. Kane appears determined to see
part of the original plan succeed - i.e. have a pretty decent size slab of the
Kane outright rejected in writing Jackson's $US1 million offer for the stamps
NPM planned to destroy. Petty bureaucracy gone quite mad in my view. NPM should
accept it with a huge grin on their face, and auction the balance. Kane worked
for 30 years for the US Postal Service until joining NPM February 2002.
I tend to agree with Eric Jackson and Arthur Morowitz ..... sell the LOT, and
let the open free market set the eventual values. Hey - the Americans tell us
they INVENTED "free enterprise"!
Jackson is running an e-poll on his website www.ericjackson.com with the
question: "Should the National Postal Museum sell the revenue stamps
archive? Let them have your opinion."
As this piece was typed mid July the poll results to date were:
Stop the destruction and sell them all - 568 votes
Retain the original plan/destroy most, but sell a select few stamps - 16
Seems very clear to me what most revenue collectors wish to see occur here. I
invite you to add your vote to the poll - you can see it update in real time,
and read the 100s of comments left by others.
I have just returned from a few weeks in and
around Fairbanks Alaska on the Arctic Circle. My third visit there, and I just
love the area. First up the LONGEST flights I have ever done without a hotel
stop. Four continents in a "day" - quite literally! Over 17,050 m or 27,470 km
one-way from SYD-Kuala Lumpur-AMS-Minneapolis to Fairbanks Alaska. Took 48 hours
in planes and airports. My 3rd trip to Alaska and such a great place to be in
Temperature was 90º and sunny the day I left - 20º warmer than Sydney! Drove for
1600 miles and saw lots of wildlife and fun stuff. A quite massive bull moose in
Denali Park that weighed about half a ton. Grizzly bear mothers 3 cubs up close
a couple of times, and even a mum and cub walking along the road. Caribou,
porcupines, and all sorts of other neat animals.
Then to Dusseldorf Germany via Minneapolis and Chicago for a weekend with a
group of frequent flyer friends - the 4th annual meeting we have had. A great
place to be ... tis year was a "Jazz Rally". Then a high speed "ICE" train back
to AMS, and the long flight home via some shopping in Kuala Lumpur. Bought my
Dad a 'solid Gold' Rolex watch also a solid 'Platinum' one - cost $A20 the pair!
His last one stopped and the jeweller sneered when he took it in for repair -
threw it back at him and said "take the darn thing back to Bali or wherever you
bought it"! My Mum wanted a half gallon of Chanel #5 as she loved the last
bottle I bought - cost $A8 - identical bottle and packaging and smell as the
Want to see (or
print out) this column
EXACTLY as it appeared in 'Stamp News'?
If so click
You will need the free Acrobat Reader program installed to view it.
If you don't have Adobe Reader click image for your FREE
To order, click here.
To read ordering instructions, click here.
Instant Currency Conversion
Just click here...
Life Member: ASDA, PTS,
APS, ANDA. ALL Postage + Insurance
is extra. Visa/BankCard/MasterCard/Diners/Amex all OK, even for "Lay-Bys"!
All lots offered are subject to my usual
Conditions of Sale, copy upon request or they are
outlined in full on this Web site. Usually allow at least 14 days for order
dispatch. If you want same day shipping please go elsewhere! I
am Sydney's BIGGEST STAMP BUYER:
Post me ANYTHING via Registered
Mail for my same-day cheque.
Avoid NASTY auction "commissions" of GENERALLY 35%
(12½ + 15% + GST, etc.) AND their five-month
delays! Read for details. I
stock Australia & Pacifics nearly 100% complete
1913-1980. Ask for my
"Lothlórien," No. 4 The
Tor Walk, CASTLECRAG (Sydney), N.S.W. 2068
(Both 25 Hours, 7 Days!)
Back to Lists of Stamp Lots for Sale
Time and Temp in Sunny
Sign up AUTOMATICALLY to my world renowned bi-weekly stamp gossip mailing list!
Click here for full library of my unusual world travels!
E-mail Me - Click HERE Right Now
For Regular Specials, News,
Updates, etc and Other Great Stuff!
Click here to get back to many lists of lists of stamps for sale at low $A Nett
Click here to find out all you need to know about SELLING your stamps for SPOT
Click here for the current Monthly
"Internet Only" special offers - CHEAP!
Click HERE to read my
recent International stamp magazine articles.
Click to go back to the main www.GlenStephens.com Stamps Homepage
Instant Currency Conversion
FREE! Just click
E-mail me at email@example.com -
card shown is accepted WITHOUT fee.
Earn Frequent Flier points while buying at bargain prices!
ALL prices are in weak Ozzie Dollars. I charge NO nasty, nasty
"Buyer's Commission" on stamps like nearly every "Auction" does.