As I often say in this column .. "knowledge is power".
The rather ugly looking cut to shape Tasmania (Van Dieman's Land) 1854 4d
"Courier" shown nearby is worth about $10 normally. This one appears to have a
very large tear or crease through it - neither mentioned in the lot description.
As most collectors know this stamp (along with the GB 1854 "embossed" issue) is
largely valueless if the corners are "cut-to-shape" as this one is.
Nonetheless, and despite being cut into the design at side it auctioned May 15th
at Prestige Philately in Melbourne for way above estimate - at $1,811, when the
"buyer fees" and taxes were added.
"Why does a $10 stamp become $1,800 more valuable" you might well be asking. And
so you should.
The postmark is the key here, as it has a clear strike of the Tasmanian barred
numeral "72". Not that this is so easy to see when the stamp is turned the
"correct" way up.
stamp sells for $1,811!
I went and looked a full page offering them. I went to the
Australia Post website, and the same items were featured there in glorious
colour as a “special offer”.
This is where the "knowledge" comes into play. "72" was allocated to Norfolk
Island, when the harsh penal colony was set up there, and administered initially
from Hobart Tasmania.
The "72" canceller finally arrived on Norfolk in July 1854. The government brig
carrying it - the "Lady Franklin" initially sailed December 16, 1853, but was
forced to turn back owing to a mutiny of the convicts on board. This cancel had
only a short working life on Norfolk Island.
In May 1855 the last convicts were removed and Norfolk was presumably
uninhabited until the descendants of the mutineers from the "Bounty" arrived
April 8 1856 from Pitcairn Island. Norfolk Island was removed from Tasmanian
postal administration in October 1856, and reverted to New South Wales control.
How does one know all this? Well there are 2 excellent large handbooks on the
"Postal History and Postal Markings of Tasmania", authored by Bill Purves et al.
I typed a set into my current internet listing for $85, and to my mind these are
absolutely essential books to own if you have any interest in Tasmania postmarks
Many circular postmarks on the common 1899 "Pictorial" series are worth several
$100s each - some possibly into the 4 figure region. Likewise often very
valuable are the many manuscript cancels of wavy lines, squiggles, wiggles,
cross hatching, signature scrawls and graffiti tags which many folks assume are
worthless fiscal cancels. Not forgetting also the "2nd allocation" of numerals
that are mainly found of the small QV heads issues.
Collecting Tasmanian postmarks is a great passion for many, and many a time I
have plucked a cancel worth $100s from childhood albums or junk lots. Generally
on very common letter rate stamps otherwise valued at literally pennies each. It
takes a little practice and study to remember the scarce ones, but having books
like these makes it quick and easy to check against.
Luckily I have always had a retentive memory for postmarks of this state as they
have always fascinated me. The only serious collection I was ever tempted to
form was a complete showing of all the Tasmania circular datestamps and
instructional markings of this period. I made some decent headway, and then sold
it when made an "offer I could not refuse"! My sideline collection of $100
banknotes did however swell considerably from this transaction.
I once visited a very glamorous stamp shop in Copenhagen. Leather lounges, and
coffee machine, and very genteel and up-market surroundings and fittings.
Virtually the only thing Australasian in the store (indeed the city!) was a
large stockbook or two of 1000's of Tassie pictorials all neatly arranged into
little lines sorted per value. And all priced at about full catalogue, which I
think was about 10c-20c each.
I nonchalantly selected about 30 pictorials with nice strikes. I guessed wrong
on a few of them of course, but about 15-20 of those postmarks paid for my round
trip airfare from Australia. And a few hotel nights as well! I remember there
being a few nice examples of classics like "Springs", "Lady Bay" or "Honeywood"
among them. Clearly I was the only person in 100 years to glance through these
stamps who had any clue about Tasmania postmark rarity.
If you ever see unremarkable sounding circular Tasmanian datestamp names like
"Ridgeway" or "Bronte" or "North Franklin" or "Scottsdale West" etc on the low
value Tasmanian Pictorials in a junk lot or dealer bulk stock - each will be
worth several $100s to you for nice clear strikes. It would be just like finding
a used £2 Roo for 10c in a junk box or circuit book.
sold for $820.
Other State postmarks pricey too
The examples given above
from Tasmania are by no means isolated cases. The same May 15th Prestige
Philately auction obtained excellent prices for a range of Victoria and NSW
Illustrated nearby is a barred numeral "156" from "Running Stream" on a 2d
Diadem that otherwise would be worth a couple of dollars. This stamp sold for
$820 on an estimate of $400.
Much more modern .. and much more valuable - is the 1935 cover also shown
nearby. Many collectors and dealers would not place much importance or value on
A 2d red KGV head on cover is quite unremarkable, being the letter rate at the
time, and billions of these 2d red stamps were used for that purpose.
It sold for $2,037 based on an estimate of only $300. Nearly 7 times the fairly
sensible (to me!) looking pre-sale estimate.
Why? Well clearly the "Quarantine" cancel is unusual. I will readily own up to
my own enormous ignorance here and admit if it were in my stock and you offered
me $50 for it a month back you'd be the new owner. And I would have had a large
grin on my face at the same time. Most other dealers would if they were honest,
admit the same - in my opinion.
The sale catalogue advises only 3 other covers are recorded with this cancel.
"RMS Aorangi" arrived with cases of smallpox aboard and this cover - indeed all
mail on board was fumigated, hence the small corner clips.
Like many things publicised in this column, many other examples may exist out
there and come on to the market as the owners have no idea of their real value
until they see the prices obtained in the present market. Keep your eyes open
for anything from NSW with "Quarantine" cancels!
Why is this worth over $2000?
I have not had a chance before to comment on another superb book released in
fairly recent times on Victoria State postmarks. "Numeral Cancellations of
Victoria" by Hugh Freeman & Geoff White is volume #17 in the superb R.P.S.V. "J.R.W.
Purves Memorial Series".
This is a massive and very heavy hardbound book, weighing in at 420 large size
A4 pages. It is without doubt in my mind THE most comprehensive and easy to
follow book on any of the state's postmarks. Bill Purves would indeed by
immensely proud to see this issued in "his" series.
For any reader looking for an exciting new challenge this is one to take up.
These postmarks are found in 99% of cases on cheap letter rate stamps. They also
are widely found on Australian Kangaroo and KGV stamps up until 1917, when the
PO reprimanded Postmasters (again) for still using them but they were in fact
used right up until 1935.
Many common 1d stamps have cancels that sell for $100s. The 1d orange "1697"
illustrated nearby was in the same auction as the Tasmania and NSW and sold for
over $400. And that is only "RRR" rated. The "RRRRR" are clearly much tougher
and a "NNR" rating ("number not recorded") obviously trumps that again. Value
without that cancel - about 2¢!
Victoria issued 2100 numeral postmarkers, between #1 (Melbourne) and #2100 (King
Valley - issued November 1906). Of these 2100 numbers - despite an army of
collectors scouring the earth over several generations - some 74 different
numbers have never been sighted.
Many numbers of course exist in a myriad of styles, variants, designs and
sub-types. All are clearly illustrated and rarity rated in this book. Even some
from Melbourne #1 that most of us would regard as "common as muck are rated "RRRR"
as they are unusual designs or sub-types.
Hugh Freeman certainly has had a mass of material to sift through in his decades
long search. I first met him 25 years back when he ran Status Stamp Auctions
along with Barry Cooper. He had owned Auctions in Sydney well before that time
as well. Hugh later went on to manage Stanley Gibbons Auctions in Australia for
many years, and still calls their public auctions.
Despite handling probably many millions of stamps from Victoria the fact 74
numbers still are unseen to Hugh Freeman and other specialists offers a
challenge to all readers of this article. Hugh used to run large ads in overseas
magazines advertising to buy the elusive numerals he still sought. I recall
seeing his ads in Stanley Gibbons Part 1 catalogues for this material.
This book illustrates around 2000 actual cancels on stamps and covers - not
drawings as other state handbooks have used. The central section is in full
colour. Reproduction quality of illustrations is quite superb, and the detail
and background to the listings is exhaustive. All cancels are rated in 8
specific rarity classes - or "non-rated" meaning they are reasonably to very
This 1d stamp realised over $400.
The book also rarity rates and illustrates the earlier
"Butterfly" and "Barred Oval" cancels - also a very useful data base on it own.
EVERY dealer in the world should own this book, and it goes without saying ALL
collectors of Victoria need to have one too. Stumble across even one half decent
cancel in your lifetime and it is more than paid for.
The hard-bound A4 book comprises over 420 pages, with eight colour plates. Price
is $A150, and a deluxe limited edition (maximum 50) half-bound in leather, with
raised spine and corners and hand-marbled end papers is also available for $250.
Stamp dealer literature stockists should have copies or contact - Publications
Manager, Royal Philatelic Society of Victoria, PO Box 642, Toorak 3142. email
1956 cover gets $1,825
This possible FDC illustrated has just sold for more than a fine used £1 Brown
and Blue Kangaroo will cost you.
The cover was offered on eBay and sold May 312 for $US1,259.56. The winner
bidder was "austcovers". The underbidder at $US1234.56 was a collector using the
eBay handle "blackwood-inn". Seller was "wbarr" from San Jose California. Who
must be a very happy chappie as the first bid was a paltry 99¢!
I have showed this scan to 4 large dealers and all agree they would have gladly
taken $100 or less for it had they had it in stock. One said $10 and he'd have
Sold for more than a used £1
is Melbourne collector Frank Pauer ... co-author of a massive FDC catalogue to
be released very soon with 1000s of colour images.
I asked Frank why he had paid such an astounding sum for this item. He replied:
"It is the only one recorded to date for the 3½d No Watermark Booklet pane.
There was no official release date but Brusden White has it as July 1956."
Pauer continued: "This FDC was done by Haywood Parish, who was working in the
and there is no other 3½d booklet pane on FDC out there. This is the first
anyone has seen. Haywood Parish has done most of the no watermark stamps on
cover of which I have 7 and no other covers exist for those FDC either. There
could be one out there for the booklet pane but you think we would have seen it
by now. If an earlier FDC does come out in the open then this one is worthless".
From the eBay scan it appears to me to be an August 1 postmark, so I just hope
the ACSC is incorrect with their "July" issue date! The eBay seller did not
describe the item as a "FDC" at any time. The ACSC says that the earliest known
date of use for the 3½d no watermark was July 2, 1956. I am curious that with a
franking of 1/9d already on the cover that the sender did not send it registered
Rosenblum is even vaguer saying only "in July". And whether booklets were issued
at same time as sheet stock no-one seems to know, and that clearly is important
This is the dilemma with much peripheral material such as booklet panes and
coils etc - the precise issue date was not always announced, and keen collectors
play Russian Roulette buying such pieces. The "pioneer" collectors in any field
face many problems. If any reader has any info to shed on this matter of dates
please contact me.
Want to see (or print
out) this column EXACTLY as
it appeared in 'Stamp News'? If so click
You will need the free Acrobat Reader program installed to view it.
If you don't have Adobe Reader click image for your FREE
To order, click here. To read
ordering instructions, click here.
Instant Currency Conversion
FREE! Just click
Life Member: ASDA, PTS, APS, ANDA. ALL
Postage + Insurance is extra. Visa/BankCard/MasterCard/Diners/Amex all OK, even for
"Lay-Bys"! All lots offered are subject to my usual
Conditions of Sale, copy upon request or they are outlined
in full on this Web site. Usually allow at least 14 days for order dispatch. If you
want same day shipping please go elsewhere! I am Sydney's BIGGEST STAMP BUYER: Post me ANYTHING
via Registered Mail for my same-day cheque.
Avoid NASTY auction "commissions" of GENERALLY 35%
(12½ + 15% + GST, etc.) AND their five-month delays! Read for details. I stock Australia
& Pacifics nearly 100% complete 1913-1980. Ask for my
"Lothlórien," No. 4 The Tor
Walk, CASTLECRAG (Sydney), N.S.W. 2068
25 Hours, 7 Days!)
to Lists of Stamp Lots for Sale
Temp in Sunny
Instant Currency Conversion
FREE! Just click
me at email@example.com -
Every credit card shown is
accepted WITHOUT fee.
Earn Frequent Flier points while buying at bargain prices!
ALL prices are in weak Ozzie Dollars. I charge NO nasty, nasty
"Buyer's Commission" on stamps like nearly every "Auction" does.